Key points
- A Sharia court in Kano sentenced 19-year-old TikTok user Zainab Abubakar to five months in prison and 10 strokes of the cane.
- She was accused of insulting the Kano State Hisbah and its Commander-General, Aminu Daurawa, in a viral video.
- Amnesty International called the sentence an attack on free expression and demanded her release, and that of Muhammad Aliyu, who is held pending trial.
- The case raises a fair question: when does insult become a crime, and who decides?
- Citizens can speak up peacefully, contact their lawmakers and back legal aid.
A 19-year-old TikTok user is in prison in Kano. Her name is Zainab Abubakar, and she is from Ogun State.
On Wednesday, a Sharia court sentenced her to five months in prison and 10 strokes of the cane. The charge was alleged insults against the Kano State Hisbah and its Commander-General, Aminu Daurawa. Anyone who posts online should care about how this ends.
A video, an event and an arrest
The story began with a video that went viral. It allegedly insulted Hisbah officials.
The Hisbah had stopped Zainab and others from organising an event along Zoo Road in Kano. Soon after, she was arrested.
Two others were reportedly picked up with her. They are Ahmad Usman and Muhammad Aliyu. All three had featured in the video.
Aliyu is still in prison, waiting for his trial. We do not know from the reports what exact offence each person was charged with. We also have not seen the court’s full reasoning. The Hisbah’s own account of events was not part of what has been reported so far.
What Amnesty International said
Amnesty International reacted fast. It called Zainab’s sentence an attack on freedom of expression. It demanded her “immediate and unconditional release”.
The group said no one should be punished for giving an opinion, even when others find it offensive. Its words were strong.
“It is flabbergasting that someone can be made to appear before a court and stand trial, let alone serve a sentence and 10 strokes of cane for simply having expressed a strong opinion.”
Amnesty went further. It called the case the latest sign of what it described as sustained repression of young people by the Kano authorities. It said Hisbah officials are showing increasing excesses, especially against young people from poorer homes.
These are Amnesty’s claims. Readers should weigh them with the facts of the case. But the group also demanded Aliyu’s release on Saturday. It called his detention disproportionate and a violation of freedom of expression.
Where does the line fall?
Let us be fair to all sides. States in the north run Sharia courts, and the law gives them a place in the justice system. A community has a right to want order and respect for its institutions.
Officials, too, are human. Being insulted in a viral video is unpleasant. Nobody should be abusive online, and a good citizen argues without cruelty.
But Section 39 of the Constitution says every Nigerian has the right to freedom of expression. That right can be limited by law, but only in ways that are reasonably justifiable in a democratic society. That is a high bar.
Here is our view. Public bodies are paid for and run in the name of the people. Rude words aimed at them should be met with answers, not a prison cell. Five months in jail and 10 strokes of the cane is a heavy price for words in a video, from a 19-year-old.
Think of a young trader who films her frustration after an event is stopped. Or a student who posts a joke about an official. If an insult can bring prison, many will go quiet. And when citizens fear to speak, leaders stop hearing the truth.
There is also a question of fairness. Amnesty says those from less privileged backgrounds bear the brunt. Whether or not that is true here, the law must treat the poor and the powerful alike. The same standard should apply in every state and for every agency.
What happens next
The case is still developing. Zainab can seek to challenge her conviction through the courts, and the government has been asked to quash it. Aliyu’s trial is yet to take place.
The test is simple. Does our justice system punish harmful acts, or only hurt feelings? A strong democracy protects both order and the right to speak.
Ordinary Nigerians are not helpless here. Write to your state lawmakers and ask where they stand on speech and the powers of agencies like the Hisbah. Support the lawyers and civic groups who offer free legal help to young people. Speak up peacefully, share only what you know to be true, and keep your own words fair. Register, collect your PVC, and vote for leaders who respect the law and your voice.
What you can do
Change starts with citizens who show up. Here is how you can act on this story:
- Write to your state assembly member and ask where they stand on free speech and the powers of agencies like the Hisbah.
- Support civic groups and lawyers who give free legal help to young people facing charges over online posts.
- Speak up peacefully, share only facts you can trust, and keep your own online words fair and free of abuse.
Should insulting a government agency or its officials online be punished with jail time?
Tap to vote and see what other readers think.
Based on reporting by: Outrage as Kano court jails TikToker for ‘insulting’ Hisbah (Punch Newspapers)
Newsletter
Get stories like this every morning.
Nigeria's politics and public life, explained plainly. Choose every morning or once a week. Free, and you can leave any time.
Spotted an error? Tell us and we will correct it. Read our editorial standards.
Found this useful? Share it with someone who should read it.
